Home » Questions raised over French plan to ban ‘virginity tests’ | France

Questions raised over French plan to ban ‘virginity tests’ | France

by newsking24

In a speech on February 18, French President Emmanuel Macron, in his marketing campaign in opposition to what he calls “Islamist separatism”, touched on the problem of “virginity certificates”.

“In the Republic, one cannot require certificates of virginity to get married”, he mentioned.

Across the world, “virginity certificates” could be issued following a physician’s affirmation {that a} affected person’s hymen is undamaged, and is usually used as a prerequisite for marriage.

Some teams, in response to their religion or tradition, require that ladies and ladies be “pure” earlier than marriage, and search such checks as “proof”.

The follow is banned in international locations equivalent to Bangladesh, however authorized in others such because the United States.

The World Health Organization has affirmed that such “testing” is unscientific, violates human rights, and may have dangerous penalties for individuals who bear it.

French docs and Muslim feminists are additionally in opposition to the follow, however some have argued in opposition to a ban, saying it might hurt ladies, whereas others have advised Macron and his administration are politicising the problem.

On September 6, Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin mentioned in an interview with Le Parisien that Macron’s forthcoming separatism invoice, anticipated to be put earlier than Parliament subsequent month, would handle virginity certificates.

“Some doctors still dare to certify that a woman is a virgin to allow a religious marriage, despite the condemnation of these practices by the Council of the Order of Physicians. We will not only ban it formally, but propose penalisation,” he mentioned.

The subsequent day, Minister Delegate Marlène Schiappa reiterated the plan throughout an interview with RTL, characterising such checks as a “serious attack on citizenship and the dignity of women”.

The inside ministry final month mentioned docs who difficulty virginity certificates would face a penalty of 1 12 months in jail and a fantastic of 15,000 euros, in response to an AFP report.

At the time of publishing, France’s Ministry of the Interior and Ministry of Health had not responded to Al Jazeera’s requests for remark.

There is little data accessible on the prevalence of the follow in France, however some docs have mentioned anecdotally that there’s little or no demand for such certifications.

A press release co-signed by docs, directors, and different advocates printed in Libération final month condemned the follow as “barbaric, backward and totally sexist”, including that it was “happily extremely rare and concerns a tiny number of patients.”

However, the signatories mentioned issuing such certificates could possibly be important to those that might face violence with out them.

“What should shock public opinion is not that the doctor writes such a certificate without any legal value, but that in 2020 the requirement of virginity is still so widespread,” the assertion learn.

French gynaecologist Ghada Hatem advised France Inter that she is requested for such certificates at most thrice a 12 months, however advised that such paperwork are wanted by ladies who might very nicely endure home violence with out them.

But Israël Nisand, president of the National College of French Gynecologists and Obstetricians, helps a ban and claims to obtain requests for virginity certificates as soon as a month. He has mentioned the inspiration of the follow is “patriarchy”.

Meanwhile, ANCIC, a French abortion organisation, mentioned in September that Schiappa and Darmanin had the “wrong target by penalising health professionals”.

Some feminist and anti-racist teams say the federal government is politicising the problem.

In a press release to Al Jazeera, Muslim feminist organisation Lallab condemned the follow as “sexist and humiliating” and advised that it has a low prevalence in France.

But it added: “We do not understand why this completely peripheral issue is at the top of the French political agenda in the defence of women’s rights.”

Nta Rajel, a feminist collective of the North African diaspora, mentioned: “Darmanin himself is the subject of investigations for rape, so the fate of women is not his concern.”

In June, a case in opposition to Darmanin courting again to 2018 was reopened when a Paris appeals courtroom declared a earlier investigation into allegations he raped a girl had been insufficient. He claims that their contact was consensual and has accused the alleged sufferer of slander.

Nta Rajel added: “It is obvious that we must fight against this type of practice but it is not by banning certificates that we will help anyone because until now, it is the presence of these certificates that has helped women who need them,” the assertion learn. “As usual, the issue of women has been exploited for racist ends.”

Source hyperlink

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Select Language »
%d bloggers like this: